Raymond Hosier, a 13 year old middle shool student at Oneida Middle School in New York has been reinstated after his mother filed a federal lawsuit over what she said is a violation of her son's civil rights. The school claims the beads are not allowed, because they could be considered gang-related.

While it's exceptionally stupid policy on the part of the school distrit to ban any religous symbol as gang paraphenelia, it is likely something isn't as it appears.  Despite Hollywood depictions (rosaries have been worn by celebrities including Lindsay Lohan, Britney Spears, Dakota Fanning and soccer star David Beckham), wearing the rosary in a way that is is publically visible is deeply offensive to most Catholics. The rosary is not considered jewlery, and is viewed as a sacred aid for prayer (Catholics use it to keep count and sequence of the prayers that make up the rosary) and wearing in a way that would be a public display would be contrary to Christ's admonishment not to pray to be seen my men (Matthew 6:5).

 


Who Voted for this Story


Comments


Written by kananebula (#44)
712 days ago
It's easy to feel bad for this student because he is wearing them for such an emotional reason. Still, I don't agree with the article saying it is "exceptionally stupid policy on the part of the school district to ban any religious symbol as gang paraphernalia." It certainly is walking on thin water, but rosaries are definitely worn as gang paraphernalia. If its in the schools right to ban hats and certain colors, the rosary is hardly different. Especially, as the original poster points out, that is not how the religion intends for it to be used. Even women who wear hijabs in inner city schools are restricted to certain colors and regulations by the school because of gang issues.



Written by smarty (#1)
712 days ago
I probably was a little unfair in saying 'exceptionally stupid' as administrators are really between a rock and a hard place when it comes to dealing with religious symbols that are used as gang signs. How do you win: ban it on gang grounds, get sued on separation of church and state. Ban it because of religion, and get sued on separation of church and state. It's a no win.

That said, I'm having a hard time believing the family's case as it's ground into Catholics from an early age that the Rosary isn't jewelry, and if it is worn as such, it is to be worn under the shirt, out of sight.



Log in to comment or register here.


GoSquared LiveStats Widget


LiveStats - Real-Time Analytics by GoSquared. Watch your Website's Traffic Unfold.
Educator of the Day is your best source for education news. We cover the news the education establishment wish wasn't covered.

Username:

Password:

Remember: